So soft and really does cocoon you, so warm. I sized down 1 size based on comments and it’s perfect. The front is open and falls back if not wrapped a little around you but I have bought a lovely copper pin broach and using that when I want hands free it’s perfect and looks amazing. I wouldn’t want a button as would look less smart and would be less versatile. I bought in the sale so price I think was good value, full price maybe a little high.

Very happy with this cardigan. The colour is a rich dark grey, size was good, it still goes over a jumper adding a great layer of warmth. It's very good quality and worth the money in my opinion.

I’ve been looking for a cardigan for a while now and ordered this one initially just as a backup for another one I’ve ordered or to just try something new, not expecting I’d love it this much! This is probably the coolest and yet cosiest item of clothing I own. I love it I get the shoulder thing the other reviews mentioned - I personally like it and whenever I do want the cardigan to stay in place I use a little brooch to keep the front connected which works well and looks chic.

Far too big. I am normally size 16 but this cardigan was way too big. It was good quality and well made but I returned it as it was too big for me to wear.

Love this cardigan, thick and warm. Agree with other comments though that it is weighted much more towards the back and hence slips constantly off your shoulders. It's a real shame because it is otherwise just lovely.

Soft and incredibly comfortable. I sized down after reading other reviews and I am pleased I did. I usually wear a medium and the small is fits well and very flattering. Good quality product.

Oh my goodness I LOVE this …. BEAUTIFUL colour that the photo doesn’t do justice and such fab quality….. such an elegant sling on … more colours please ….. I love a cocoon and slipping off the shoulders is part of the appeal for me . Thank you !

It’s my favourite, I love the style and shape. Please make in navy.

Dear Sally Shaw, thank your for your lovely feedback. We will pass on your colour suggestion to our product development team. Kindest regards, Celtic & Co. Team.

I bought both the M/L and XS/S as usually I am a Medium in Celtic sweaters. The M/L was returned and I’m keeping the XS/S Lovely blue grey colour and super soft

This os a good quality woollen open cardigan, the colour is more of a cool dark bluish grey than looks in photo, I was hoping it would be more charcoal, that would be great for next colour. When trying on for size it felt like a good fit. However once I had worn it for a couple of hours it kept slipping down off both shoulders, no matter what I wear underneath it keeps slipping and I’m a bit disappointed with this. The whole length of the edge rolls inward a lot, tried rolling it outward more like a shawl collar edge which looks great but doesn’t stay as such, just rolls back inward. I don’t think this helps with the slipping off. I wish this had come in a single size as I’m always M in Celtic but had to get M/L which perhaps made it too big and slipping off. I didn’t try the small because it was a 4 week wait for order, too to buy 2 sizes and wait over 4 weeks for a refund. I will try rolling the neck edges toward and gently sewing that into place which will look better and hopefully stop the slipping off. Not something I had thought would be needed with a Celtic garment at this price, my overall reasons for giving 3/4 stars.